Speculation and the Absence of True Scholarship

I just have to say that this is the kind of teaching so typical in the charismatic/word of faith movement. Firstly traditional scholarship (coming from those with true academic credentials) is dismissed out of hand as having missed the entire point of the passage. With that out of the way, with almost apostolic announcement, the “true” meaning of the passage is given. There is never a reference to other scholars who have come to the same conclusion. The teacher has spoken and all we hoped to understand is now revealed, and of course, the “revelation” leaves the listener/reader totally dependent on the charismatic teacher to understand this and any other passage.

Rick Renner (the man in the above video) writes, “Just about the time Jesus finished healing the ear of the servant of the high priest named Malchus, the Gospel of Mark tells us a naked young man was found in the Garden of Gethsemane. Mark 14:51,52 says, “And there followed him a certain young man, having a linen cloth cast about his naked body; and the young men laid hold on him: and he left the linen cloth, and fled from them naked.” Who was this young man? Why was he following Jesus? Why was he naked? Why was he draped in a linen cloth instead of wearing normal clothes? And why was the Holy Spirit so careful to include this unique story in Mark’s account of the Gospel? What is the significance of this event? Take a moment today and watch this short clip, I think it will really give you something to THINK ABOUT today!”

The two fold problem with all this:

1) The supposed insight he gives is the height of speculation rather than revelation. To use an analogy from the world of building construction – a sky scraper doctrine is built on a just a dime of real estate.
2) The conclusion reached is complete and utter blasphemy. In this case, Rick Renner states that Jesus raised a naked boy from the dead by accident! Yes! You read that correctly!

R C Sproul summed up the problem well: “Although tradition does not rule our interpretation, it does guide it. If upon reading a particular passage you have come up with an interpretation that has escaped the notice of every other Christian for two-thousand years, or has been championed by universally recognized heretics, chances are pretty good that you had better abandon your interpretation.”

Hermeneutics, Exegesis and the Ordo Salutis

“The ordo salutis, Latin for ‘the order of salvation’ is the theological doctrine that deals with the logical sequencing of the benefits of redemption as we are united to Christ which are applied to us by the Holy Spirit.”

Dr. James White speaks to the issue of a consistent hermeneutic derived from sound exegesis of the Biblical text and takes us on a journey looking closely at the constructions in 1 John 2:29, 1 John 4:7, and 1 John 5:1, then responding to comments made by Leighton Flowers which attempt to avoid the weight of what 1 John 5:1 teaches about faith and regeneration.

Starts at the 40:00 minute mark:

Though You Slay Me

Though You Slay Me by Shane and Shane (featuring John Piper)

Lyrics:

I come, God, I come
I return to the Lord
The one who’s broken
The one who’s torn me apart
You struck down to bind me up
You say You do it all in love
That I might know You in Your suffering

Though You slay me
Yet I will praise You
Though You take from me
I will bless Your name
Though You ruin me
Still I will worship
Sing a song to the one who’s all I need

My heart and flesh may fail
The earth below give way
But with my eyes, with my eyes I’ll see the Lord
Lifted high on that day
Behold, the Lamb that was slain
And I’ll know every tear was worth it all

Though You slay me
Yet I will praise You
Though You take from me
I will bless Your name
Though You ruin me
Still I will worship
Sing a song to the one who’s all I need

Though tonight I’m crying out
Let this cup pass from me now
You’re still all that I need
You’re enough for me
You’re enough for me

Though You slay me
Yet I will praise You
Though You take from me
I will bless Your name
Though You ruin me
Still I will worship
Sing a song to the one who’s all I need
Sing a song to the one who’s all I need